Skip to content

WEEKLY RANT: Ukip and the dangers of sophistication

May 29, 2014

20140529-091044.jpg

There has been much in the media about why Ukip did well in last week’s elections elsewhere, but not in London. “London is out of touch with the rest of the country” is the claim. As if elections are not an aggregate result which consists of individual decisions capable of being affected by different circumstances in different areas.

Adjectives are being advanced to explain the conundrum: London is “sophisticated”, “cosmopolitan”, “media-savvy”, “bohemian”. They often drip with a venom that would suggest that these are all bad things to be. Someone even suggested during a papers review the next day that Londoners are “overeducated” – presumably this is what happens where one who had aimed for “just educated enough”, overshoots into some thoroughly ghastly state of being too well informed. Well, replacing The Crucible on the schools curriculum with Run For Your Wives should soon take care of that.

All these hypotheses ignore two important factors: First, if Ukip’s policies were thorough, well argued and coherent, presumably they would have been even more successful with the sophisticated and media-savvy. Second, Ukip achieved results below its national average in many other cities and also Scotland.

Another popular theory is that London is doing better in the economic recovery, so of course Londoners are less worried and selfish about it in the bargain. This is also misconceived. Recovery is an average. Kensington and The City may be doing incredibly well, but areas like Tottenham, Hackney or Ealing have some of the highest unemployment rates in the country. And, since London is much more expensive, poor people in London are suffering a much more dramatic squeeze than anyone else. The idea that the electorate in Tottenham rejected Ukip because they are more well-to-do than leafy villages in Oxfordshire where Ukip did well, is manifestly absurd.

The most obvious reason of all has been almost completely ignored. People who live in areas where those of different races, religions, nationalities and cultures live together in, broadly, mutually beneficial harmony, are more likely to see Ukip’s apocalyptic warnings for what they really are: an enormous pile of alarmist xenophobic horseshit.

The following statistic was mentioned during the BBC’s election night coverage: in areas where more than 75% all-white households, Ukip experienced a notably higher uplift. This is because fear as motivator works best when amorphous and diffuse. And people are much more likely to vote for measures which propose to victimise a general, anonymous group, rather than one which includes friends, colleagues, partners and neighbours whom they know and respect.

I am reminded of what Greek composer Manos Hadjidakis said:

“Nazism, fascism, racism and every other anti-social and anti-human mode of behavior are not products of ideology, do not contain ideology and neither do they constitute ideology. They’re the expression of the beast within all of us growing unchecked, when its barbaric and inhuman presence is aided, enhanced or facilitated by sociopolitical circumstance.
“The only antibiotic against this beast within, is education. I am talking about real education and not the irresponsible education of indiscriminate information which actually supresses restless and critical thinking. I am talking about education which does not rest on its laurels and does not create complacency in the student, but instead propagates questions and insecurity. This kind of education is not favored by political parties and governments, because it produces free-thinking and unruly citizens, who are of no use in the lowly game of politics.”

Perhaps that is what they mean by “overeducated”.

6 Comments leave one →
  1. rsoap permalink
    May 29, 2014 9:09 am

    Should be compulsory reading for every secondary school student. 

    Sent from Samsung Mobile

  2. May 29, 2014 9:24 am

    Reblogged this on sdbast.

  3. Pauline Burney permalink
    May 29, 2014 2:12 pm

    The political knee jerk response “we will focus more on immigrants”, in response to UKIP results worries me- why not spend time and money on exposing the deeply faulted claims and statistics as a recent radio 4 programme did wonderfully well.
    Why don’t they also highlight the personal and financial contribution made by migrants to this country. The Scottish Government openly admit that with falling birthrates and aging population we need people to move in.
    As a health professional I can tell you that the highest levels of breast feeding, consistent effective parenting and well managed households are a reliable feature of the multi national homes I visit.
    Mr Hadjidakis is a very wise man.

  4. Mark permalink
    June 1, 2014 1:38 am

    Completely agree with so much of this but there’s absolutely no suggestion about how we deal with the problems that immigration is causing. How do we deal with the very real issues in places like Page Hall? Just tell the people there that it’s a result of globalisation and that immigrants make a net contribution to British society?

  5. June 2, 2014 5:09 pm

    “Adjectives are being advanced to explain the conundrum: London is “sophisticated”, “cosmopolitan”, “media-savvy”, “bohemian”. They often drip with a venom that would suggest that these are all bad things to be.”

    Much the same argument has been made elsewhere. Recently in Quebec, the Partis Quebecois used similar statements professing that Montreal was an ideological island distant from the “pure lain” of the more rural areas. It was also largely a xenophobic campaign which tried to pose solutions to problems that did not exist. You summed it up so well saying “…fear as motivator works best when amorphous and diffuse.”

  6. June 3, 2014 1:25 pm

    I came to the UK ten years ago… ten years ago the environment was on front pages… I was really impressed with this attitude… I perceived Britain and the British media as very mature and caring… that was ten years ago… so much has changed ever since… it makes me want to cry…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,484 other followers

%d bloggers like this: